EDR vs MDR is one of the most common comparisons organisations encounter when evaluating modern cyber security solutions. As security technologies evolve, many businesses are investing in Endpoint Detection and Response (EDR) tools but remain uncertain whether this alone provides sufficient protection, or whether Managed Detection and Response (MDR) is the next necessary step. While the two are closely related, they serve fundamentally different purposes. Understanding the difference is essential for organisations looking to move from simply detecting threats to actively defending against them.
Do we need MDR?
One of the most frequent questions we hear is simple: if we already have EDR, do we really need MDR?
Cyber security conversations increasingly include terms such as EDR, MDR, XDR and SOC, yet many organisations remain unsure how these fit together in practice. Although Endpoint Detection and Response and Managed Detection and Response are closely connected, they play very different roles in protecting an organisation. Understanding that distinction is key when assessing the maturity of your cyber security capability and determining whether your current approach delivers real protection or simply visibility.
This guide explains the difference between EDR and MDR, when each is appropriate, and why many organisations are now moving beyond standalone tools towards managed security outcomes.
What is Endpoint Detection and Response (EDR)?
Endpoint Detection and Response is a security technology designed to monitor activity on endpoints such as laptops, desktops and servers.
Unlike traditional antivirus software, EDR continuously records system behaviour and analyses activity to identify suspicious patterns that may indicate an attack.
Typical EDR capabilities include:
- Behavioural threat detection
- Malware and ransomware identification
- Endpoint visibility and telemetry collection
- Device isolation and containment tools
- Investigation dashboards for analysts
EDR provides deep technical visibility into what is happening across devices. It is a powerful detection platform and forms a critical foundation of modern cyber security.
However, EDR is fundamentally a technology platform. It generates alerts and intelligence, but it does not replace the people and processes required to act on them.
What is Managed Detection and Response (MDR)?
Managed Detection and Response builds upon EDR technology by combining detection tools with human expertise, continuous monitoring and active incident response.
Rather than simply providing alerts, MDR delivers an operational security capability managed by cyber security specialists.
An MDR service typically includes:
- 24/7 monitoring by security analysts
- Threat investigation and validation
- Proactive threat hunting
- Incident containment and response
- Security optimisation and tuning
- Ongoing reporting and guidance
In simple terms:
EDR gives you visibility. MDR gives you defence.
MDR transforms detection technology into an actively managed security function without requiring organisations to build their own Security Operations Centre (SOC).
| Capability | EDR | MDR |
| Type | Security technology | Managed security service |
| Monitoring | Internal team responsibility | 24/7 managed monitoring |
| Threat investigation | Manual | Performed by analysts |
| Incident response | Customer led | Provider supported or executed |
| Expertise required | High internal expertise | Included within service |
| Coverage | Endpoint focused | Endpoint, cloud, identity and network context |
| Outcome | Alerts and visibility | Active protection and response |
The distinction is not about better technology, but about operational responsibility.
Contact UsFor More Information
The Real Difference: Tools vs Outcomes
Many organisations deploy EDR expecting it to automatically protect them. In reality, EDR often creates a new challenge: managing alerts.
Security teams frequently experience:
- Hundreds of alerts per week
- Limited time to investigate incidents
- Uncertainty around severity
- No monitoring outside business hours
- Alert fatigue and missed threats
Detection without response creates risk.
MDR addresses this gap by ensuring alerts are analysed, prioritised and acted upon continuously.
Instead of asking “Did we detect something?”, MDR answers “Has the threat been contained?”
Benefits of EDR
EDR remains an important component of any security strategy and offers several advantages:
- Deep visibility into endpoint behaviour
- Advanced detection beyond antivirus capabilities
- Investigation tooling for skilled analysts
- Integration with wider security platforms
- Strong foundation for security maturity
For organisations with dedicated security teams, EDR provides powerful investigative capability.
Benefits of MDR
MDR extends those benefits by adding operational resilience.
Key advantages include:
Continuous Protection
Threats do not operate on office hours. MDR provides round the clock monitoring and response.
Access to Security Expertise
Organisations gain experienced analysts, threat hunters and incident responders without hiring internally.
Faster Response Times
Rapid investigation and containment significantly reduce potential business impact.
Reduced Burden on IT Teams
Internal teams focus on business delivery rather than security alert management.
Improved Cyber Resilience
Security becomes proactive rather than reactive.
Contact UsFor More Information
Should You Choose EDR or MDR?
The right choice depends less on technology and more on organisational capability
EDR may be suitable if:
- You operate an internal security team or SOC
- Analysts are available 24/7
- You have defined incident response processes
- Security monitoring is a dedicated function
MDR is often better suited when:
- Security responsibilities sit with general IT teams
- Monitoring is limited to working hours
- Alert volumes are difficult to manage
- The organisation is growing or becoming more complex
- Regulatory or client assurance requirements are increasing
For many organisations, MDR represents the natural next step in cyber maturity.
Where Does XDR Fit In?
Extended Detection and Response (XDR) expands detection beyond endpoints to include identity, cloud platforms, email and network telemetry.
XDR improves visibility across environments, but like EDR, it remains a technology platform.
MDR services increasingly leverage XDR capabilities, combining broad telemetry with human expertise to deliver stronger detection and response outcomes.
Why Organisations Are Moving from EDR to MDR
Cyber-attacks have changed.
Modern threats are:
- Faster
- Automated
- Multi-stage
- Designed to evade traditional controls
The challenge is no longer detecting threats but responding quickly enough to stop them.
MDR allows organisations to achieve enterprise grade security operations without enterprise level staffing or cost.
The shift reflects a wider industry trend:
Security is moving from ownership of tools to ownership of outcomes.
Contact UsFor More Information
EDR vs MDR: Frequently Asked Questions
No. MDR typically uses EDR as a core technology layer. MDR enhances EDR rather than replacing it.
Yes, but MDR augments internal teams by handling monitoring and response activities.
No. Many mid-sized organisations adopt MDR because building a 24/7 SOC internally is unrealistic.
MDR supports compliance by improving monitoring, incident response readiness and audit visibility.
Final Thoughts EDR vs MDR
EDR and MDR are not competing solutions. They represent different stages of cyber security maturity.
EDR provides the tools to detect threats.
MDR provides the expertise and operational capability to stop them.
For organisations seeking stronger resilience without expanding internal security teams, MDR bridges the gap between technology investment and real-world protection.
You may be interested in our Managed Detection & Response service page.
Amicis Group would love to discuss any aspect of your cyber security and see how you can best be supported.
We’d welcome a call from you on 0333 305 5348 or feel free to use our Contact Us page
